top of page

The Importance of Finite Element Analysis in Pre-Clinical Testing of Total Knee Arthroplasty

Updated: Feb 8, 2023

Total knee arthroplasty, also known as knee replacement surgery, is a complex medical procedure that requires precise and reliable design and testing to ensure optimal patient outcomes. That's where finite element analysis (FEA) comes in.

Introduction

FEA is a powerful simulation tool that allows designers and engineers to test and optimize the performance of products and systems before they are manufactured. By using FEA, companies can reduce the need for physical testing and save time and money by identifying and fixing design flaws early in the development process. For more information on the basics of finite element analysis, be sure to check out our previous blog post on the subject.

In the field of total knee arthroplasty, FEA can be used to simulate the performance of knee implants and evaluate their response to real-world conditions. By using FEA to model the anatomy, mechanics, and loads of the knee, designers and engineers can evaluate the strength and durability of different implant designs and make informed decisions about which designs are most likely to perform well in clinical trials and in real-world use.

However, not all FEA consulting services are created equal. It's important to choose a provider with the expertise and experience necessary to conduct accurate and reliable FEA simulations. At NRP, our FEA consulting services have been utilized to conduct numerous FEA experiments on a variety of structures, materials, and systems, resulting in improved product performance and reduced need for physical testing. We have a track record of success in using FEA to inform design decisions and improve overall product reliability.



If you're looking for a reliable and experienced partner for your FEA needs, look no further than NRP. Our team of highly skilled FEA experts is ready to help you take your total knee arthroplasty products to the next level. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you optimize your designs and ensure the reliability of your products.

For more information click here

 

Contents


 

What is the Best Implant for Total Knee Replacement?

The answer to this question will depend on a variety of factors, including the patient's anatomy, medical history, and lifestyle. However, FEA can be a valuable tool in determining which implant is likely to perform best for a particular patient. By using FEA to simulate the performance of knee implants and evaluate their response to real-world conditions, designers and engineers can make informed decisions about which designs are most likely to perform well in clinical trials and in real-world use.


 

Are Knee Implants FDA Approved?


Yes, knee implants must be approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) before they can be marketed and sold in the United States. The FDA has established rigorous standards for the safety and efficacy of medical devices, and knee implants must meet these standards in order to be approved. What is the Newest Technology in Total Knee Replacement? There are several new technologies in the field of total knee replacement, including:

  • Customized knee implants that are tailored to the patient's unique anatomy.

  • Minimally invasive surgical techniques that reduce trauma and improve patient outcomes.

  • Computer-assisted surgical systems that improve the accuracy and precision of knee replacement surgery.


 

What is the Difference between Total Knee Replacement and Total Knee Arthroplasty?


Total knee replacement and total knee arthroplasty are two terms that are often used interchangeably to describe the same procedure. Total knee arthroplasty refers to the surgical replacement of a damaged knee joint with an artificial joint, while total knee replacement specifically refers to the replacement of both the thighbone and shinbone. How Many Types of Knee Implants are There? There are many different types of knee implants available, including:

  • Total knee replacements

  • Partial knee replacements

  • Revision knee replacements


 

What are the Different Types of Knee Implants?

  • Total knee replacements replace both the thighbone and shinbone in a damaged knee joint.

  • Partial knee replacements replace only one portion of the knee joint, typically the inner portion.

  • Revision knee replacements are used to replace a previously implanted knee joint that has failed or become damaged.


 

What are the Three Types of Knee Replacements?


The three types of knee replacements are:

  • Total knee replacements

  • Partial knee replacements

  • Revision knee replacements


 

Fatigue Testing of Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Comprehensive Study on Tibial Tray Durability


Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is a surgical procedure aimed at improving the functioning and quality of life of patients suffering from knee joint problems. A critical aspect of TKA is the durability and reliability of the knee implant components, such as the tibial tray. Fatigue testing of TKA components is crucial to ensure the longevity and safety of the implants. This article focuses on the fatigue testing of tibial tray components of TKA and its importance in optimizing the design and reliability of TKA products.


Methodology

The fatigue test of the tibial tray was conducted in accordance with the ASTM F1800 standard. The tibial tray was fixed as a cantilever beam, with half of the tray fixed on one side and the other half supported by a load applicator. The load applicator applied a cyclic compressive force on the unsupported side via a spherical load applicator, perpendicular to the superior surface of the tibial tray. The test was performed using an electromechanical test system, and the stress ratio was 0.1. The test environment was at 25°C temperature and 55% relative humidity, with a test frequency of 2 Hz.

For more information click here


The fatigue test of the tibial tray from ASTM F1800


Results and Validation

The fatigue test was terminated if cracks were observed or if the predetermined number of cycles (10 million cycles under a maximum load of 900 N) was achieved. To validate the finite element analysis (FEA) model, the maximum compressive force of 200 N was applied to the tibial tray, and the normal strains were measured using strain gages. The normal strains were multiplied by the modulus of Ti-6Al-4V alloy to obtain the normal stress, which was compared with the calculated stress from the FEA validation.


Testing Conclusion

Fatigue testing is an essential part of the product development process for TKA components, such as the tibial tray. This study provides a comprehensive overview of the fatigue testing methodology for tibial tray components and its importance in optimizing the design and reliability of TKA products. The results of the study validate the accuracy of the FEA model, demonstrating the effectiveness of fatigue testing in ensuring the safety and longevity of TKA implants.


 

Benefits of using FEA for pre-clinical testing in TKA

By utilizing Finite Element Analysis (FEA) for pre-clinical testing in Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA), companies can enjoy numerous benefits, including significant time and cost savings, improved accuracy, and reduced need for physical testing. The use of FEA allows for detailed simulations of TKA components, providing insights into the behavior of the implant under various loading conditions. Additionally, the use of strain gauges can provide valuable data during testing, and FEA can help identify critical stress locations and localize areas of high stress concentration. These benefits of using FEA for pre-clinical testing of TKA can lead to improved product performance and increased overall reliability.

 

Conclusion


At NRP, our FEA consulting services have a proven track record of success in using FEA to inform design decisions and improve overall product reliability. We are highly skilled in using FEA to conduct simulations and fatigue testing on a variety of structures, materials, and systems.


In the context of total knee arthroplasty, FEA can be an incredibly valuable tool in pre-clinical testing. By using FEA to simulate the performance of knee implants, designers and engineers can make informed decisions about which designs are most likely to perform well and provide the best outcomes for patients. Additionally, FEA can help identify potential weaknesses or areas for improvement in a design, allowing designers to make changes before moving forward with clinical trials.


At NRP, we believe that FEA is a critical component of the pre-clinical testing process, and we are dedicated to using this technology to help our clients develop the best and safest knee implants possible. If you're looking for a reliable and experienced partner in your pre-clinical testing process, look no further than NRP.


 

65 views0 comments
bottom of page